Everything Language and Grammar

Stupid Grammar Error

Posted by languageandgrammar on May 9, 2008

All right, let’s just dive right into this stupid thing.

Recently, a professional athlete was quoted in an article as saying I made the stupidest mistake. The athlete was talking about his personal life—his VERY personal life. (It’s hard to keep track these days, isn’t it?)

The superlative form of stupid is most stupid, as in I made the most stupid mistake, not stupidest. Stupidest can be heard and seen everywhere, but it’s wrong. (Please don’t ask me to roll out my entire exposition on why finding a word in a modern dictionary doesn’t make it legitimate, standard English. Paul and I have already paddled across that ocean several times.)

Stupid is just like lucid (same -id ending). The comparative form is more lucid, and the superlative form is most lucid. Likewise, the comparative form of stupid is more stupid, and the superlative form is most stupid. In fact, in general, -id words use more and most instead of –er and –est. (The water was more tepid, he was the most lucid, they could have been more candid, his reflexes have grown more torpid, the milk was the most rancid, his tongue had grown more acrid. No one would even think to say tepidest, lucidest, candidest, torpidest, rancidest, or acridest.)

Oddly enough, as many times as I’ve heard the word stupidest (and believe me, if I sold my soul to the devil in order to have eternal life, that wouldn’t be long enough for me to count the number of times that I’ve heard it over the past few years), I’m not sure that I’ve ever heard anyone use the word stupider (even though it is now given as an alternative form in some modern dictionaries!). Maybe that’s because people know how stupid the word stupider sounds and that the correct form is more stupid. Then why don’t they know how stupid stupidest sounds and that the correct form is most stupid?

Regardless, the aforementioned athlete may have made the most stupid mistake in his personal life, but he also made a mistake when he used the word stupidest.

I hope that we can now lay this stupid grammar error to rest.

Sherry

Paul’s book–Literally, the Best Language Book Ever;

Sherry’s Grammar List

About these ads

4 Responses to “Stupid Grammar Error”

  1. Judy said

    Now this is new to me! And I’m no dummy when it comes to correct grammar. I frequently pick out errors in newspapers, advertisements, & even in scientific journals so to read your comments about stupidest is very interesting – thank you! I like to pride myself on using the correct grammar. I found it amusing that when I typed ‘stupidest’, it didn’t show a red colour as spelling errors normally do. Shows how ubiquitous the word has become in our language. Oh, if you find spelling errors in my comments (like colour), it’s because I’m Canadian. And no, I never say “eh”. :)

    Reply: Thanks, Judy. I’m not surprised at your spell checker. Mine likes the substandard words ANYWAYS and IRREGARDLESS, too. :)

  2. John said

    Have you explained “why finding a word in a modern dictionary doesn’t make it legitimate, standard English”? What does make something standard English?

    Reply: Yes, we have talked about it on a couple of different occasions.

  3. Please don’t ask me to roll out my entire exposition on why finding a word in a modern dictionary doesn’t make it legitimate, standard English.

    And the corollary to that: Just because you Google a word and turn up 2,000 instances of it doesn’t make it right!

    Reply: Amen! :) Common usage—even 2000 of them—isn’t necessarily correct usage.

  4. […] Re: Has the average person become stupider in last 5000 years? Stupid Grammar Error Everything Language and Grammar […]

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 150 other followers

%d bloggers like this: